All Worlds News

Brazil’s Lula: Saint or sinner?

Brazil’s Lula: Saint or sinner?
12 September 2018 - 2:15 'was also added 115 Viewed.
This 22 March 1979 file photo shows Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva being lifted by metalworker colleagues after a union rally in Sao Bernardo do Campo, 55kms from Sao Paulo. Da Silva, presidential candidate for the Workers' Party, has been declared the winner of the presidential election run-off 27 October, 2002. Image copyright Getty Images Image caption Lula started his political career with the metalworkers’ union

Luiz Inácio “Lula” da Silva is seen as much as a saviour as he is a sinner in Brazil: a man who came to power promising change yet ended up leaving politics with a very different legacy.

His life mirrored that of many Brazilians. He was born in 1945 into a poor family in the north-east of Brazil and, by the time he was seven, his family had moved to São Paulo to find work – as many millions of Brazilians have done, before and after him.

‘Only death will take me off streets’

Lula did not learn to read until he was 10. At the age of 14, he got his first job as a metal worker in the car factories on the outskirts of São Paulo.

It was in those factories that he started getting involved in politics. By 1975, he was heading the metalworkers’ union and, throughout the 1970s and 80s, he helped organise major strikes in defiance of Brazil’s military rule.

“The working class has never got anything in this world without a battle, without perseverance and without the will to fight until the end,” he told workers in April 1980.

Image copyright Getty Images Image caption Lula’s campaign slogan in 2002: “I want a decent Brazil”

But it was a long struggle to the top. Lula ran for president unsuccessfully three times before eventually being elected in 2002.

And when he was, he made history as Brazil’s first working-class president, who argued it was time for Brazil to turn a new page.

“Change: that was the key word, that was the message from Brazilian society,” he said as he was sworn in, in January 2003. “Society decided it was time to forge a new path.”

He led Brazil during a period of unprecedented economic growth. High prices for commodities meant that he had money to spend on social programmes.

Image copyright Getty Images Image caption Lula ran for the presidency three times before being elected in 2002

One of his biggest legacies was lifting millions out of poverty, according to his former foreign minister, Celso Amorim.

“Taking 30 to 40 million people out of poverty is fantastic,” says Mr Amorim.

“They [Brazilians] identify with Lula because he’s one of them, coming from poorer parts, then becoming a metal worker, and then all the way to the presidency, without departing from these origins.”


But he also faced criticism for spending money without addressing the core problems in society.

“Everyone was happy because everyone had access to credit,” argues political analyst Thiago de Arago. “This is a mechanism that didn’t come from the brilliance of an economic plan but from the circumstance of the moment.”

The good times could not last forever. After serving two consecutive terms in office, the maximum allowed under Brazil’s constitution, Lula stood down on 1 January 2011.

Image copyright Getty Images Image caption Lula was Dilma Rousseff’s mentor and he made her his chief of cabinet

His ally Dilma Rousseff succeeded him as president but as economic growth slowed, political dissatisfaction grew.

In 2013, protests that started over a rise in bus fares grew into a widespread expression of anger with corrupt politicians, a situation that intensified with the start of Operation Car Wash in 2014, the biggest corruption investigation the country has ever seen.

Brazil corruption scandals: All you need to know

Lula was a man who said he would represent change, but in the end, he too was charged with corruption.

‘You can’t arrest my ideas’

In 2017 he was sentenced to nearly a decade in prison over allegations he accepted a beachfront apartment in return for political favours from a construction company.

In 2018, his sentence was extended to 12 years.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionLula forced his way through crowds of his supporters to turn himself in

It is a charge that has divided Brazil between those who feel that he and his Workers’ Party have been unfairly treated and those who believe justice has been served.

Lula’s legacy is mixed. “It proved that in a country like Brazil today, he cannot be protected just because of how big he was,” says Mr Arago. “I think this is a major legacy that Lula will leave for Brazilians: that no one is above the law.”

For months, he fought to remain out of jail, but in April the Supreme Court said he had to start serving time.

From the metalworkers’ union where he began his career, he gave his last speech: “There is no point in trying to end my ideas, they are already lingering in the air and you can’t arrest them. There is no point in trying to stop me from dreaming, because once I cease dreaming, I’ll keep dreaming through your minds and your dreams.”

“They have to know that the death of a fighter cannot stop the revolution,” he said to the crowd.

And even behind bars Lula has kept up the fight. But it is one he has finally lost and which has led to the fall from grace for the man who was once Brazil’s most popular politician.

He is out of politics now but still in the minds of many and will continue to be formidable influence in Brazilian politics for a while to come.


This post has been commented on.